Current:Home > MyRobert Brown|South Carolina inmates want executions paused while new lethal injection method is studied -FundTrack
Robert Brown|South Carolina inmates want executions paused while new lethal injection method is studied
Will Sage Astor View
Date:2025-04-10 04:41:06
COLUMBIA,Robert Brown S.C. (AP) — Lawyers for six death row inmates out of appeals in South Carolina are asking the state Supreme Court to give full consideration to the state’s new lethal injection rules as well as the electric chair and firing squad before restarting executions after an unintended 12-year pause.
The inmates said judges should decide now if the state’s new lethal injection protocol using just the sedative pentobarbital as well as killing prisoners by electrocution or shots fired into the heart do not violate the Constitution’s ban on cruel and unusual punishments.
“The next set of potential plaintiffs are already in line, and more will follow. Now is the time to finally resolve these questions,” attorneys for the condemned inmates wrote in court papers filed Friday.
Lawyers for the prisons and Gov. Henry McMaster asked the Supreme Court on Sept. 19, the same day they announced the lethal injection drugs were available, to toss out a lower court ruling that the electric chair and firing squad were cruel and let executions start as soon as possible.
Prison officials said they were able to obtain the lethal injection drug because the General Assembly passing a shield law in May allowing the state to keep secret the procedure for executions and the suppliers of drugs or other items used.
South Carolina had previously used a three-drug combination and couldn’t obtain any more after the last batch expired 10 years ago without keeping the supplier secret, halting executions in a state that once had one of the busiest death chambers in the country.
The shield law means South Carolina doesn’t have to reveal its protocols for lethal injection, but Corrections Director Bryan Stirling said it is essentially identical to how the federal government and several other states use pentobarbital alone to kill inmates.
But the lawyers for the South Carolina prisoners said both the inmates waiting to die and the justices can’t just take Stirling’s word and need to be able to see and review the new rules so they can decide if lethal injections are reliable and effective.
Pentobarbital compounded and mixed has a shelf life of about 45 days, so the lawyers for the inmates want to know if there is a regular supplier and what guidelines are in place to make sure the drug’s potency is right.
Too weak, and inmates may suffer without dying. Too strong, and the drug molecules can form tiny clumps that would cause intense pain when injected, according to court papers.
In his sworn statement after obtaining the sedative, Stirling said he and his employees made more than 1,300 contacts to buy or obtain lethal injection drugs.
Having to search so hard and so long “necessarily raises concerns about the quality and efficacy of the drugs,” the inmates’ argument said.
Also in question is a lower court ruling after a summer 2022 trial that the electric chair and lethal injection are cruel and unusual punishments.
The judge sided with the inmates’ attorneys who said prisoners would feel terrible pain whether their bodies were “cooking” by electricity or had their hearts stopped by marksman’s bullet — assuming they are on target.
Attorneys for the state countered with their own experts who said death by the yet-to-be-used firing squad or the rarely-used-this-century electric chair would be instantaneous and the condemned would not feeling any pain.
“Respondents face selecting blindly between a method of execution of uncertain efficacy (lethal injection) and two antiquated methods that the circuit court has deemed unconstitutional due to the pain and damage each method is certain to cause,” the lawyers for the inmates wrote Friday.
South Carolina has 34 inmates on its death row. The state last killed someone on death row in May 2011.
veryGood! (1617)
Related
- A South Texas lawmaker’s 15
- Kentucky agriculture commissioner chosen to lead state’s community and technical college system
- 2 Indianapolis officers indicted for shooting Black man who was sleeping in his car, prosecutor says
- Dianne Feinstein was at the center of a key LGBTQ+ moment. She’s being lauded as an evolving ally
- Nearly 400 USAID contract employees laid off in wake of Trump's 'stop work' order
- 'We feel your presence': Stephen 'tWitch' Boss' widow, kids celebrate late DJ's birthday
- French police are being accused of systemic discrimination in landmark legal case
- Emerging election issues in New Jersey include lawsuits over outing trans students, offshore wind
- New Mexico governor seeks funding to recycle fracking water, expand preschool, treat mental health
- 2 Mexican migrants shot dead, 3 injured in dawn attack on US border near Tecate, Mexico
Ranking
- Finally, good retirement news! Southwest pilots' plan is a bright spot, experts say
- Europe sweeps USA in Friday morning foursomes at 2023 Ryder Cup
- NFL's new gambling policy includes possibility of lifetime ban
- Duke's emergence under Mike Elko brings 'huge stage' with Notre Dame, ESPN GameDay in town
- Newly elected West Virginia lawmaker arrested and accused of making terroristic threats
- Jon Rahm responds to Brooks Koepka's accusation that he acted 'like a child' at the Ryder Cup
- How Former Nickelodeon Star Madisyn Shipman Is Reclaiming Her Sexuality With Playboy
- New York flooding live updates: Heavy rains create chaos, bring state of emergency to NYC
Recommendation
Elon Musk's skyrocketing net worth: He's the first person with over $400 billion
Allison Holker Honors Beautiful, Sweet Stephen tWitch Boss on What Would've Been His 41st Birthday
'Surreal': Michigan man wins $8.75 million in Lotto 47 state lottery game
Europe masterful at Ryder Cup format. There's nothing Americans can do to change that
IRS recovers $4.7 billion in back taxes and braces for cuts with Trump and GOP in power
Michael Oher's Conservatorship With Tuohy Family Officially Terminated
Over 93,000 Armenians have now fled disputed enclave
Rejected by US courts, Onondaga Nation take centuries-old land rights case to international panel